Are you tired of scrolling through Netflix, only to see the same old movies? Look no further! We’ve curated a list of the most underrated and hidden gem movies on Netflix that you absolutely must watch. These films encompass a wide range of genres, from indie flicks to horror gems, and even big studio movies that somehow slipped under the radar.
Unearth Hidden Gems and Underrated Films
If you’re tired of the same old movie choices on Netflix, we’ve got your back. Our carefully curated list features the most underrated movies that may not have made a big splash upon their initial release but are absolutely worth your time. From obscure horror gems to star-studded vehicles that deserve a second look, these films share one common trait: they are exceptionally good. Dive into our selection of the finest hidden gems and underrated movies currently available on Netflix.
Can’t Find What You’re Looking for on Netflix?
Don’t worry if you don’t spot your desired film on our list. We have recommendations for you! Explore our handpicked selection of hidden gems on other streaming platforms like Disney+, HBO Max, and Prime Video. You’re sure to find a captivating movie to enjoy.
Editor’s Note: A New Addition in August 2023
Our movie list is up-to-date, featuring the latest hidden gems on Netflix. Be sure to check out the newest addition, “Polka King,” added in August 2023.
“Barry” (2016): A Unique Coming-of-Age Drama
Run Time: 1 hr 44 min | Genre: Drama | Director: Vikram Gandhi
Join us on a journey through the college years of future President Barack Obama in “Barry.” This unconventional biopic focuses on his formative years, highlighting the development of the skills and charisma that would propel him to greatness. Devon Terrell’s breakout performance transforms this iconic figure into a relatable teenage protagonist, making “Barry” a coming-of-age story with a John Hughes-like charm. For fans of Anya Taylor-Joy, don’t miss out on one of her early standout roles. — Liam Gaughan
“Polka King” (2017): A Hilarious Take on the American Dream
Run Time: 1 hr 35 min | Genre: Biography, Comedy | Director: Maya Forbes
“Polka King” brings to life the incredible true story of Jan Lewan, a Polish-American polka band leader who orchestrated a Ponzi scheme that led to his downfall. Jack Black takes on the role of Lewan, using his polka band as a front to attract unwitting investors. While the real-life events were less lighthearted, the film manages to infuse humor and heart, creating a sympathetic portrayal of a man who defrauds the elderly. — Tauri Miller
“Kodachrome” (2017): A Powerful Exploration of Family
Run Time: 1 hr 45 min | Genre: Drama | Director: Mark Raso
“Kodachrome” is a poignant exploration of family, second chances, and forgiveness. Jason Sudeikis stars as Matt, the estranged son of a renowned photographer played by Ed Harris. Their emotional journey unfolds during a road trip to the last lab developing Kodachrome film. With Elizabeth Olsen portraying Ben’s charming nurse, this bittersweet film delves deep into the complexities of their relationships and life choices. Perfect for a night of heartfelt storytelling. — Yael Tygiel
“The Land of Steady Habits” (2018): A Tale of Choices and Regrets
Duration: 1 hour and 38 minutes | Directed by: Nicole Holofcener
Based on Ted Thompson’s novel, “The Land of Steady Habits” takes us into a wealthy Connecticut community, where retired divorcee Anders, portrayed by Ben Mendelsohn, seeks happiness. His journey unfolds through his estrangement from his wife and son, and his unexpected friendship with a teen drug addict. With a touch of humor, this film delves into life’s choices and regrets, offering an honest portrayal of human complexity. — Yael Tygiel
“Tallulah” (2017): A Touching Comedy-Drama
Run Time: 1 hr 51 min | Genre: Comedy Drama | Director: Sian Heder
“Tallulah” reunites Elliot Page and Allison Janney in a heartwarming tale of compassion. Page plays Tallulah, who, in a desperate act, rescues a baby from a neglectful mother. This feature directorial debut from Sian Heder balances comedic elements with deep emotional truths, showcased by remarkable performances. With tender gentleness, “Tallulah” explores the consequences of unconscionable circumstances, offering a synthesis of comedy and drama. — Yael Tygiel
“Candy Jar” (2018): A Hidden Teen Rom-Com Gem
Duration: 1 hour and 32 minutes | Genre: Romantic Comedy | Directed by: Ben Shelton
“Candy Jar” offers a delightful take on teen romance. Lona and Bennett, initially rivals on the debate team, find themselves unexpectedly competing together. As they discover common ground and perhaps even deeper feelings, this enemies-to-lovers story shines. Supported by the delightful performances of Christina Hendricks and Uzo Aduba as their quirky but loving moms, “Candy Jar” is a teen rom-com you won’t want to miss. — Taylor Gates
“I’m Thinking of Ending Things” (2020): A Masterful Surrealist Thriller
Run Time: 2 hr 14 min | Genre: Surrealist Psychological Thriller | Director: Charlie Kaufman
Prepare for an unsettling cinematic experience with “I’m Thinking of Ending Things.” This film follows a young woman’s visit to her boyfriend’s parents’ farm, creating an uncomfortable and symbolic journey rich in emotion. Directed by Charlie Kaufman, it prioritizes emotion over plot, offering masterful direction and performances that will leave a lasting impact. — Taylor Gates
“Wheelman” (2017): A Pulsating Neo-Noir Thriller
Run Time: 1 hr 22 min | Genre: Neo-Noir Crime Thriller | Director: Jeremy Rush
Netflix’s “Wheelman” offers a pulse-pounding thrill ride reminiscent of “Drive” and “Locke.” Set entirely behind the wheel, Frank Grillo delivers a charismatic performance as a getaway driver who discovers he’s been set up. If you crave a tight, action-packed thriller under 90 minutes, “Wheelman” has you covered with its gripping narrative. — Liam Gaughan
“Mindhorn” (2016): A Hilarious British Action-Comedy
Run Time: 1 hr 29 min | Genre: Comedy | Director: Sean Foley
“Mindhorn” is a British action-comedy that combines the best of Steve Coogan and Monty Python. Julian Barratt shines as the washed-up star of a cult TV series who becomes embroiled in a real murder mystery. The film doesn’t take itself too seriously, delivering a delightful mix of